Listen in to hear Melissa, Bridger and Caleb discuss the article, “Dependency in the Treatment of Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and Dissociative Disorders” by Onno van der Hart.
Title of Article:
Dependency in the Treatment of Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and Dissociative Disorders (2001) Onno van der Hart
“The Haunted Self” – Amazon
This article was written by a group that is influenced by psychoanalytic thought, Object Relations Theory and neurobiology. This article is a blend of all three of these concepts/theories.
Potential discomfort of the idea of dependency
- This goes back to the late 19th century
- Freud’s main posture was interpretations of the client’s thoughts.
- This article use modern analytic theory, noticing limitations
- “Dependency is a necessary therapeutic dynamic for the process of healing.” This can be very uncomfortable for therapists.
Why does the idea of dependency make us nervous?
- Free association- getting too involved in the process
- Intense self-disclosure of the therapists
- Why as a client should I trust you if I know nothing about you?
- The fear of dependency or addiction
- Lastly, there is culture shame about needing others.
- Females are socialized to be more comfortable with dependency and it’s the opposite for males.
- The recreation of mother and child as adults is shunned and seen as weakness.
When we don’t know what to do as female therapists, a nurture instinct comes out.
- Firstly, when the cognition fails, it feels like all we have to fall back on is the nurturing experience.
- Secondly, this isn’t an instinct to everyone, including many woman.
- Is that enough and is that okay to do?
- The innate expression of nurture is a physical, right-brained experience.
- Our western culture is encouraging us to be left-brain therapists.
- Lastly, this issue is not settled as a culture, nor as a profession.
Dependency and the needs of the clients
- Strange Situation- measuring styles of attachment (John Bowlby)
- Whoever is taking the role of the nurturer and meeting needs is the primary caregiver.
- We cannot continue as a species without early attachment to primary caregivers.
- Attachment vs. dependency
- Dependency: “A manifestation of attachment that includes a wide range of conscious and unconscious behavioral strategies and related affect in cognition. The purpose of dependency, as opposed to attachment in general, is specifically to procure caretaking. I.e.- needing direct support and guidance from
- Dependency is more about procuring or securing access to resources. It is a “need” that our life depends on.
- Dependency is a strategy that is used to get the attachment need met.
- There’s secure and insecure dependency.
- Active dependency: This is in line with secure attachment in that the needs are expressed and actively sought after. When referring to PVT, the use of sympathetic activation is occurring in this type of dependency.
- Passive dependency: occurs from insecure attachment, the dismissiveness of the need. This is more of a dorsal shutdown, the fawn response. This, however, is still dependent.
- Shout out to episode 1!
How does a person with a dismissive attachment style get their needs met?
- The tendency to wish the therapist will just tell me what to do so that there’s a celebration for the “performance me” through which validation and security is achieved.
- Letting the therapist take control of the sessions, which creates a disintegrated experience.
- The need for dependency is being met in a round-about way so that therapy further exacerbates the attachment malfunction.
- This occurs when the client is still seeking proximity, without directly addressing needs.
- This is insecure attachment through the expression of passive dependency.
- Always pulling the therapist in further intersubjective space.
What about preoccupied attachment?
- Aggression in various forms- what is the most efficient way to get you to meet my needs?
- This is coupled with internal panic if the need doesn’t get met.
- We aren’t even aware that there’s another way to achieve our needs because this attachment style is so pronounced. The need to find safety in another is so intense.
- Labeled as “aggressive” “too much” and “in your face”
What’s a disconfirming experience for dismissive strategies?
- When one meets the need with neither of strategies but in an open and direct way is a disconfirming experience.
- It’s upsetting and it shows that their strategy failed. It evokes the question of why they needed to develop this strategy anyways.
- “I see what you need and I’m going to speak it and help you realize I’m with you.”
- What the ANP is avoiding is the grief of the unmet attachment need. So with a dismissive orientation we are prohibiting the grief from emerging.
- When we call out the grief, we are inviting the activation of the area of the brain, or circuit, that holds grief.
- Healthy dependency: Our nervous system has an attachment need for someone to see and feel your grief, and in turn, their activation state of nurture and care comes to offer that. This allows the part of us that has a need to be met that wasn’t met consistently in the past.
What’s a disconfirming experience for preoccupied strategy?
- Oftentimes occurs alone when they begin to think of why people don’t care about them.
- This occurs in an emotional spin out. The person will reach out to the person who we feel distant from and then accuse them of not caring about us. This oftentimes may cause a confirming experience because the person may become defensive in response to our spin out.
- The message is that what’s happening internally, is something that no one would ever want to experience with you.
- This style is known to forcefully get their needs met.
- A disconfirming experience would be for whoever we are trying to extract that need from, sits in the chaos and is present with them, but doesn’t solve it.
Deciphering between a need and a wish:
- Understanding if the client’s dependency is based on a need or a wish.
- A futile wish to get a previously unmet need met.
- The need to be rightfully angry about not getting our needs met.
- Make room for the anger to display and act out.
- Dismissive: omitted affect and distorted cognition
- Preoccupied: distorted affect and omitted cognition
- Try to see it not as a wish, but an unmet need in the past.
The natural growth of dependency across development
- There’s a natural flow from dependency to interdependence to autonomous independence.
- We almost don’t want to foster dependency at all, just interdependence.
- Noticing when we are dependent, interdependent or independent.
- Being aware and being flexible
- First, understand what trauma does with our levels of dependency and how it influences how we form attachment styles. It’s a very normalizing experience to accept that dependence, interdependence and autonomy are all regulatory functions that we move in and out of.
- Attachment and dependency are very interrelated concepts and help us better understand our clients.
- The difference between wishes and psychobiological needs. The push and pull in the intersubjective space to expose the client’s wish as well as then find the need and grieve that together.
- Lastly, “Good therapy includes fulfilment of need and gentle frustration of wishes.” You no longer need that strategy, your need is now here.